?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Just a quick rant... - A Sorta Fairytale
October 2013
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
 
hymnia
hymnia
Joie
Sun, Aug. 13th, 2006 06:27 pm
Just a quick rant...

If you don't know what this is about already, here is the necessary background info.

It really bugs me that people are somehow able to believe that angiej/Ebony's lifting of several lines and--more significantly--the structure of a very pivotal and memorable scene from Anne's House of Dreams and using them in Trouble in Paradise without crediting LMM is not plagiarism.

YES, IT IS!!!

Oh, how I remember the night I found that passage, over a year ago. I searched and searched for a citation, because I remembered hearing about the whole CC thing and how the BNFs had assured people that whatever she and any of them borrowed was cited--and like a litle child, I believed! I looked at the beginning and end of that chapter in TiP, throughout the chapter, at the previous chapter, at the next chapter, at the first chapter, at the last chapter for any mention that Ebony had borrowed from one of my favorite authors, whom she also claimed as one of her favorite authors. I liked Ebony, darn it. Not that I ever knew her personally, but I had lurked at her journal and liked most of what I saw there, and despite all the things that some of my fandom-oldbie friends said, I always just felt like I should give her the benefit of the doubt. I remember feeling sure that the citation must be somewhere and I was just overlooking it.

But there's no citation, and I'm sorry, but just because it's only a few lines and the two scenes show a similar and somewhat common circumstance doesn't excuse it. I don't believe for a second that it could have been subconsious. That scene in LMM's book is intense--it's not likely to be forgotten, especially by someone who is a particular fan of the author. Also, it's not just the words itself that are lifted. There are some important details that Ebony also borrowed, which I think are what make LMM's scene so effective: one, that the husband is the one who has the job of informing his wife of the loss, and two, that the POV is taken away from the grieving woman's room as she cries out. The first detail increases the intensity of the scene, while the second undercuts it. It creates a climax, and then gives the reader a bittersweet relief. It's brilliant writing, IMO, and Ebony stole it, and it makes me angry that people refuse to recognize that.

ARGH! Sorry if I'm being wanky, but I hardly ever go off on the things in fandom that bug me, at least not publically. I think it's my turn to rant. >:|

Joie

Tags:
Current Mood: angry angry

4CommentReply

lilac_bearry
lilac_bearry
Lilac
Mon, Aug. 14th, 2006 12:39 am (UTC)

Yes it is your turn!


ReplyThread
xray2000
xray2000
xray
Mon, Aug. 14th, 2006 01:28 am (UTC)

ARGH! Sorry if I'm being wanky, but I hardly ever go off on the things in fandom that bug me, at least not publically. I think it's my turn to rant. >:|

Glad to see you're normal :D


ReplyThread
tesgirl123
tesgirl123
tesgirl123
Mon, Aug. 14th, 2006 12:58 pm (UTC)

Stealing Anne and Gilbert is a travesty. And the fact that people don't see it as stealing is disgusting. Its understood that we are playing with JKR's characters, but to outright steal LLM's work and not giving credit is stealing.


ReplyThread
meahtsingan
meahtsingan
meahtsingan
Mon, Aug. 14th, 2006 04:09 pm (UTC)

Coming from some parts of the fandom, I can see how they might conclude plagiarism isn't stealing. As demonstrated by all the illegal downloading going on, there's clearly a LOT of people out there who don't understand, care about, and/or believe in intellectual property rights. But for that trio, given their professions, to claim they've done nothing wrong, legally or ethically, is sickening.


ReplyThread